Supplier quote comparison

Enter the offers from two or three suppliers and your expected sales. The calculator compares the cost of every unit you can actually sell, including freight, duty, defects and the money sitting in stock.

Your sales

Units sold in an average month.
Rate on your credit line or loan.
Quote 1
Excluding VAT.
Minimum units per order.
Per order. Zero if delivered to your warehouse.
Zero for EU suppliers.
Moulds, samples, certifications.
Unsellable units out of the total.
Days from order to arrival.
Quote 2
Excluding VAT.
Minimum units per order.
Per order. Zero if delivered to your warehouse.
Zero for EU suppliers.
Moulds, samples, certifications.
Unsellable units out of the total.
Days from order to arrival.

Comparison

Enter expected monthly sales and the price of at least one quote.

How do you compare two supplier quotes?

Total cost per unit = (landed cost + financing cost) ÷ sellable units, where landed cost = (quantity × price + freight) × (1 + duty) + one-off costs.

With 400 sales a month and an 8% cost of capital, supplier A quotes €4.20 per unit with a 3,000-unit MOQ, €900 freight, 4% duty, 6% defects and 60 days lead time. Supplier B quotes €5.10 with a 500-unit MOQ, €250 freight, no duty, €150 one-off costs, 1% defects and 20 days. A costs €5.16 per sellable unit and B €6.01, so A saves about €4,076 a year. In exchange A ties up €14,040 of capital and covers more than 7 months of sales, so the calculator flags the high MOQ.

The list price is only the starting point. A cheaper supplier may ask for a high MOQ, forcing you to buy months of stock and tie up cash. It may sell ex works, leaving freight and duty to you. It may have more defects, which reduce the units you actually sell. The calculator puts all of these on the same basis, the cost of one sellable unit, so you compare like with like.

The financing cost estimates what the tied-up money costs you. You carry it from order day to arrival, then on average for half the period in which you sell the stock, because inventory runs down gradually. Use the rate on your credit line or loan as the cost of capital, or the return you give up by using your own funds. If the best offer covers more than six months of sales, try negotiating a lower MOQ or split deliveries: the price often rises a little while the capital tied up drops a lot.

Questions about comparing quotes

What is the cost per sellable unit?

It is the landed cost of the order divided by the units you can sell, net of defects. If you order 1,000 units and 50 are defective, the cost is divided by 950.

How do I enter freight and duty if the price is delivered?

If the offer is delivered duty paid (DDP), leave freight and duty at zero because they are already in the price. For ex works (EXW) or FOB offers, enter the freight you pay and the duty rate for the product. For suppliers inside the European Union, duty is zero.

Why is the ordered quantity different from the MOQ?

The ordered quantity is the larger of the MOQ and one month of sales. If the MOQ is below monthly sales, the calculation assumes an order that covers at least one month.

What value should I use for the cost of capital?

The yearly rate you pay on a credit line, invoice financing or loans. If you buy with your own funds, use the return you give up. If you are unsure, try two or three values and see whether the cheapest offer changes.

Where do I find the duty rate for my product?

It depends on the product's customs code and country of origin. You can look it up in the European Commission's TARIC database or ask your freight forwarder.

Does the calculator include VAT?

No. Enter prices and costs excluding VAT: for a business that reclaims VAT, the tax is not a cost. If you cannot reclaim it, add it to price and freight before comparing.

More ecommerce calculators

Guide to ecommerce product profitability